Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Nutella Nutter Butter Ice Cream

I have to tell you a secret....PROMISE you wont tell anyone! I know I can trust you! I am having a LOVE affair! YUP!.....With my Ice Cream Maker!!!
My husband and I received this Ice Cream maker for a wedding present almost 14 years ago! And I can honestly say I think I have used it more in the last week and a half than all 13+ years.  I am loving coming up with new recipes to try out. My daughter and husband are loving it even more. 
Nutella Nutter Butter Ice Cream
Who doesn't love chocolate and peanut butter together? And this is loaded with mini Nutter Butter Cookie Bites. Oh my heck!...stop your drooling. (lol)

1 C. Cold Whole Milk
2 C. Heavy Cream
2 tsp. Vanilla (or you can kick it up with cold coffee)
3/4 C. Sugar
1 (3.4 oz) Vanilla Instant Pudding
2 TBSP Creamy Peanut Butter (heaping)
2 TBSP Nutella (heaping)
4 oz. container Nutter Butter Bites

Start by stirring the milk, cream, sugar and vanilla together until sugar is dissolved. Whisk in the pudding, until smooth. Add in the Peanut Butter whisking. Do the same with the Nutella. I leave little "clumps" of both. So no need to beat it smooth. Now you will follow your Ice Cream machine directions. In the last 5 minutes of mixing add in the Cookie Bites. I then freeze it so it will really "set up" for at least a couple of hours. You will be amazed at how creamy this is...you might want to double the recipe!

Cool and Creamy Treats,
Lark 

12 comments:

Gloria said...

Lark this look amazing! gloria

The Better Baker said...

How are you doing this woman??? This recipe is insanely amazing! WOW!!! What a way to enjoy this refreshing summertime treat!

Laurie Alves said...

Absolutely Wonderful! Cant wait to try it!

Lisa @ Flour Me With Love said...

Chocolate and Peanut Butter, one of my favorite things :)

Joy @ Joy Of Desserts said...

I love my ice cream makers too. :-) I'll have to try this soon.

Kim McCallie said...

I have agonized and debated all summer whether I should get an ice cream maker or not. Then, I see recipes like this and I want one. This sounds delicious. Thanks for inspiring and sharing on Sweet Indulgences Sunday.

Good Girl Gone Green said...

My ice creamer consists of 2 bags and salt. I am sure this would work better...lol

Rosa said...

Oh, that looks so good!! Just yesterday, I mentioned to my husband that maybe we should get an ice cream maker... we concluded that it might be to dangerous! ;) I'll save your recipe just in case... :)

Denise said...

Ok made and in freezer to get frozen, could not find little nutter butters so I got regular cookies and chopped them up. YUM cannot wait to try tonite !!!

Debi....Recipes For My Boys said...

I'm drooling! I want an ice cream maker!!! I have to make mine in the freezer, which takes forever!! Thank you for the wonderful recipe, sweetie! Save a bite for me. <3 and hugs!

Christine Dopp said...

This really gives me an idea or two for ice cream concoctions!! this is a must try Im sure it will be great . Just last night I made a smoothie with 3 tsp of nutella about 1/2 cup plain yogurt 4 oz of milk a dash of evaporated milk too, a splash of honey and a small frozen banana and about 4-6 frozen whole strawberries it was sooo yummy! I got the choc fix i needed and without all the calories of a milk shake I had been craving! I wonder if I put it all in my ice cream maker if id get a decent ice cream hmmmmm lol

shelly said...

i love you! lol .this is incredible.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...